315: Regenesis
What’s Covered?
Roster Watch



Synopsis
Regenesis
X-Men: Regenesis #1
Writer - Kieron Gillen
Pencils - Billy Tan

Schism is over, and everyone has to choose a side. Psylocke takes charge of Utopia's defenses, while Beast heads to Westchester because he's convinced Wolverine will need him to actually run the school. Toad is apparently getting a job as janitor. Storm initially chooses Logan, but Scott points out that his new team is packed with former villains and he needs someone like her keeping them honest. Emma is furious that Scott assumed she'd stay, especially when she wanted to teach, but she remains on Utopia and even agrees to help fund it. I like that this split is already about more than who agrees with Scott or Logan.
Meanwhile in Utopia
Uncanny X-Men vol. 2 #1
Writer - Kieron Gillen
Pencils - Carlos Pacheco

Scott unveils the Extinction Team, a collection of mutant heavy hitters whose mission is to save the world so often that people will have to respect them. Storm asks the team who has never been considered a villain, and then challenges Scott for raising his hand. That is a pretty good way to introduce this roster. Meanwhile, Psylocke handles Utopia's security, the X-Club is still around, and Sinister murders humans before awakening the sleeping Celestial. His attack quickly leaves Colossus flattened and Emma missing an arm. The new team has barely assembled before it's in serious trouble.
Uncanny X-Men vol. 2 #2
Writer - Kieron Gillen
Pencils - Carlos Pacheco, Jorge Molina, Rodney Buchemi

Sinister has transformed an entire town into variations of himself. These clones have individual personalities, but they're all part of a society devoted to Sinister. He claims the original Mister Sinister is dead and that this new version is an improvement. When Agent Brand announces that the Celestials are coming, Sinister is delighted because he expects them to wipe out everyone who isn't one of him. Even shooting him doesn't work. One clone simply starts talking where another left off, revealing that Sinister is now a whole system instead of one person. It's been a while since a villain genuinely excited me, and this version of Sinister is a very promising start.
Uncanny X-Men vol. 2 #3
Writer - Kieron Gillen
Pencils - Rodney Buchemi, Paco Diaz, Carlos Pacheco

Hope uses Emma's telepathy to shield the team from Sinister's control, while Sinister tells Hope that her future involves the Phoenix. Danger reassembles herself and gives the X-Men room to fight back. Then Emma learns that Scott's DNA is central to Sinister's design and uses everything she knows about Scott's mind to take his clones apart. She pays for it when she leaves diamond form and her missing arm becomes a very real problem, with Namor helping keep her alive. Sinister simply evolves again and escapes. When the Celestials arrive, Scott boldly tells them the X-Men will protect Earth and points to the Dreaming Celestial as proof. Amazingly, they leave. Scott's plan to make the Extinction Team impossible to ignore just got its first big victory.
Uncanny X-Men vol. 2 #4
Writer - Kieron Gillen
Pencils - Brandon Peterson

A standalone story follows a being who was tortured, isolated and cut off from others, then became obsessed with absorbing people and growing stronger until the X-Men finally destroyed it. It's an unusually grim little diversion after Sinister and the Celestials. There isn't much character material in my notes here, so I'm not going to pretend it has the weight of the preceding three issues.
Meanwhile at the Mansion…
Wolverine and the X-Men vol. 1 #1
Writer - Jason Aaron
Pencils - Chris Bachalo

Wolverine opens the Jean Grey School for Higher Learning, with Kitty as headmistress. That's a pairing I've wanted to see take on more responsibility for years. Professor Xavier thinks Logan is ready, although an inspection of the new school immediately suggests otherwise. Rachel teaches psychic self-defense, Husk handles mutant literature, and apparently every room can become a Danger Room. Broo, the empathetic young Brood who intrigued me in the last blog, is now a student, alongside Kid Gladiator and his bodyguard Warbird. Unfortunately, the young Hellfire Club's Kade Kilgore announces that he intends to keep attacking the school. Logan wanted a place where kids could be kids. Nobody appears interested in making that easy.
Wolverine and the X-Men vol. 1 #2
Writer - Jason Aaron
Pencils - Chris Bachalo

The Hellfire kids unleash Frankenstein monsters with flamethrowers on the school, because apparently a normal first semester would be too much to ask. In a flashback, Logan challenges Bobby to stop coasting on his untapped potential and help run the place. Bobby responds to the invasion by creating an entire army of sentient ice creatures. I've complained about Iceman being boring in the past, but this is certainly a different way to use him. Broo also has a crush on Idie, which is oddly sweet. Then there's another problem: the school has been built on a version of Krakoa, the living island. Quentin Quire thinks he can handle it. I am not enjoying Chris Bachalo's art on these scenes, to put it mildly.
Wolverine and the X-Men vol. 1 #3
Writer - Jason Aaron
Pencils - Chris Bachalo, Duncan Rouleau, Matteo Scalera
Quentin Quire actually talks to Krakoa, who turns out to be a descendant of the original island and wants to become an X-Man. Considering how much trouble Quentin caused during Schism, it's interesting to see him solve a problem by talking instead of escalating it. Meanwhile, Matt Murdock informs Kade Kilgore that the school is suing him for hundreds of millions of dollars. Kade responds by turning to Sabretooth for help. So Logan has managed to get a school open, but he has inherited a remarkable collection of enemies along with his students.
My Connections and Creators
Boring or Great?
Ok, here we are. A new phase. I considered creating one of those "Favorites as of..." posts, which typically serves an official break between phases, but since Cylcops is still on Utopia, I didn't feel like it was a big enough break. We'll see though, maybe I was wrong.
I thought the Utopia phase up until now was pretty good, but I really missed having distinct teams. Every X-book was just one giant cast. And while the casts are still pretty darn big, I've always liked it when we could focus in a specific team and devote more time to character development.
So the first team, the team that stayed with Scott on Utopia, is made up of all the heavy hitters, calling themselves the Extinction team. That's kind of a lame name (and concept,) but this initial story was anything but. This Sinister story was exceptional. If the quality can stay this high, which would be hard, I would consider this a top run. Sinister has always felt like one of the best villains, so bringing him back, and changing him so fundamentally, is pretty amazing.
Anyone who's read more than one of my blogs knows that I'm the "Kitty guy." I can't get enough Kitty. So naturally, I love Kitty as headmistress. I also love her dynamic with Wolverine. However, there are a few headwinds here. First, this young Hellfire club stuff is so dumb. Why isn't editorial stepping in here. They have to know how dumb this is! So then you take this dumb concept, and you throw in Chris Bachalo to make it even more unrealistic. No thank you. I don't hate this, but I"m struggling here. Also, the whole "now the entire mansion is a danger room..." That idea. It's dumb, too.
Thoughts on Art
Billy Tan handles the Regenesis transition, while Carlos Pacheco and several supporting artists bring Sinister and the Celestials to the new Uncanny X-Men. Brandon Peterson handles the fourth issue. Chris Bachalo draws the first three Wolverine and the X-Men issues, with Duncan Rouleau and Matteo Scalera joining on #3. I really don't like Bachalo's art here, especially the rampaging Frankenstein monsters and Bobby's army of ice creatures.
Larger Impacts & Things to keep an eye on
What's going on with Hope and the Phoenix power?
How long will Colossus continue on as Juggernaut?
Can we keep momentum going after that Sinister arc!
Can we kill off these young Hellfire Club kids?
Is the roster still too big? Only time will tell.



Comments